Odd Classes of Prohibitions

A Prohibition which is not similar to the prototypical prohibition against Muzzling an Animal while it threshes, doesn't receive Whipping: Pesachim 41b (2x); Makkot 13b, 15a

Prohibitions which are worded with the negative instruction "Al": Eruvin 17b

Whether such a transgression is punished with lashes, or not: Pesachim 63b, Bava Kama 5a; Makkot 2b, 4b, 13b, 16a, 20b; Zevachim 29b; Temurah 3a-4b

Prohibition against abuse of Hashem's Name as a Prohibition without an associated Deed: Pesachim 63b; Makkot 16a

Considering cursing a person with Gd's Name a prohibition without an associated deed: Makkot 16a; Temurah 3a, 3b

Whether we consider the attempt to exchange an animal in another's place as an offering as a deed-less prohibition, or whether its speech is its deed: Makkot 16a; Temurah 3a-b

Considering Swearing falsely or without purpose as a deed-less prohibition: Temurah 3a-b

Considering speech as a deed for Witnesses caught trying to falsely incriminate someone [Edim Zomimin]: Bava Kama 5a; Makkot 2b, 4b; Keritot 4a

Tithing Terumah from produce before separating out the first fruits: Temurah 3a, 4a-b

Whether a Migadef must bring a korban chatat [sin offering], since no deed is involved: Keritot 2a [2x], 3b-4a, 7a

Summoning the dead via Ov or Yidoni: Keritot 7a

Processing a korban with a thought of pigul: Zevachim 29b

General lists of examples of this class: Makkot 4b, 16a; Temurah 3a; Keritot 3b-4a

No whipping for a "Spectrum" prohibition: Pesachim 24a, 41b; Temurah 7b; Keritot 4a, 5a

Examples: Pesachim 24a, 41b; Temurah 7b; Keritot 4a, 4b-5a, 5a

Whether there is whipping for such a Prohibition: Pesachim 41b, 42a; Makkot 18b; Zevachim 34a

Examples: Pesachim 41b, 42a; Makkot 18b; Zevachim 34a

No whipping for such a Prohibition: Pesachim 95a; Makkot 13b, 14b-16b, 17a; Temurah 4b-5a

Examples: Pesachim 95a; Bava Metzia 62a; Makkot 14b-16b; Temurah 4b

Whether there are lashes for a person who fails, at some point, to fulfill the positive action, or only for a person who creates a situation where the positive action is unfulfillable: Makkot 15a-16b

Whether there is a punishment of whipping if the Positive Action was fulfillable before the violation ever occurred, as opposed to a situation where the positive action is merely corrective: Makkot 14b-15a

Considering a prohibition to fit into this class because the prohibited act is legally recognized as effective (Example: Sanctifying an animal in a forbidden manner): Temurah 4b

No Whipping for such a Prohibition: Shabbat 154a; Makkot 13b; Eruvin 17b

Examples: Shabbat 154a; Eruvin 17b

A Warning for a Prohibition [Azharah] can't come from a Kal VaChomer: Pesachim 24a; Makkot 5b, 17b

The validity of a warning which is worded positively, rather than negatively [Azharat Aseh]: Temurah 4a

Lending money for interest: Bava Metzia 60b, 70b-71a

Withholding an employee's wages: Bava Metzia 61a



Back to Home

Search by Category

Search by Google WWW Webshas

Alphabetical Index

About WebShas